Black Friday can bring a welcome increase in orders for retailers. But when a company is already struggling with cash flow, higher sales don’t necessarily mean more money in the bank.

Discounts, stock purchases, delivery costs, advertising and refunds can all put additional pressure on working capital. A successful sales campaign could even make an existing cash-flow problem worse.

The important question isn’t how much you can sell. It’s whether the company can afford to fulfil those sales and meet its other commitments.

Before increasing discounts or advertising spend, directors should understand the contribution each order makes and how the campaign will affect cash over the coming weeks.

Start with contribution, not turnover

A busy checkout can create the impression that business is improving. But turnover alone doesn’t tell you whether the campaign is profitable or sustainable.

For each product or bundle, consider:

  • The selling price after discounts, allowing for the applicable VAT treatment.
  • Stock costs, including freight, import duty and minimum-order commitments.
  • Marketplace, card-processing and payment-provider fees.
  • Advertising, affiliate commissions and promotional costs.
  • Picking, packing, packaging, delivery and additional staffing.
  • Expected cancellations, returns, refunds and chargebacks.

The amount remaining is the order’s contribution towards fixed overheads such as rent, payroll, tax and finance costs.

If that contribution is too small, selling more products may increase the company’s workload and financial exposure without generating enough money to meet its commitments.

What does a Black Friday sale actually contribute?

Consider a retailer processing 100 discounted orders at £60 each.

For this example, all sales are assumed to be standard-rated for VAT, with the £60 selling price including VAT.

Illustrative cash bridge: 100 discounted orders

itemillustrative amount
Customer receipts£6,000
VAT element(£1,000)
Stock cost(£2,400)
Payment and marketplace fees(£300)
Fulfilment, delivery and packaging(£900)
Campaign advertising(£700)
Contribution before fixed costs and returns£700

Illustrative example only. The figures aren’t industry averages and assume a 20% VAT rate. Actual costs, VAT treatment and payment dates will vary.

The calculation leaves £700 before rent, existing payroll costs, finance payments, returns, chargebacks and other overheads.

That £700 isn’t necessarily available cash.

Some stock may already have been paid for, while other suppliers may still need paying. The payment provider may not have released all customer receipts, and future refunds could reduce the amount ultimately retained.

The example is useful for understanding the campaign’s economics, but it isn’t a substitute for a cash-flow forecast.

Timing can turn a profitable campaign into a cash-flow problem

Even where sales generate a positive contribution, the timing of payments can create difficulties.

A retailer may need to buy stock weeks before Black Friday. Advertising platforms might collect their fees before customer receipts are settled. Warehousing, additional staff and courier costs could fall due while orders are still being processed.

Some payment providers also operate settlement delays or reserves, depending on their contracts.

That means a campaign can appear profitable while the company’s bank balance is falling.

Directors should put the campaign into a rolling cash-flow forecast using realistic payment dates.

The forecast should include:

  • Opening bank balances and expected cleared receipts.
  • Stock purchases and outstanding supplier commitments.
  • Fulfilment, delivery and staffing costs.
  • Rent, payroll, PAYE and VAT liabilities.
  • Existing creditor arrears and finance repayments.
  • Expected refunds, cancellations and chargebacks.

It’s sensible to prepare a daily cash forecast during the campaign and a weekly forecast covering at least the following 13 weeks.

It’s also important to test what happens if customer receipts arrive later than expected or refunds are higher than forecast.

Customer payments aren’t automatically available to settle older debts

When customers place orders, the retailer takes on obligations to supply the goods or provide an appropriate remedy if it cannot fulfil the contract.

That can require further spending on stock, staff, packaging and delivery.

There are also consumer rights to consider.

Buying an item in a Black Friday sale doesn’t remove the customer’s statutory rights where goods are faulty or misdescribed. For most online purchases, consumers also have cancellation rights, subject to the applicable exceptions.

Directors should therefore calculate the realistic cost of completing accepted orders and meeting potential refund obligations before deciding how much cash is available for other commitments.

This becomes particularly important where the company already owes money to HMRC, its landlord or suppliers.

It doesn’t mean that every pound received from customers must be held in a separate account. It means there needs to be a credible, funded plan for meeting the company’s obligations rather than relying on sales receipts that may already be needed elsewhere.

Four Black Friday cash-flow scenarios

1. Positive contribution and sufficient cash

The campaign makes a worthwhile contribution, and the company has enough funding to fulfil orders and meet its wider commitments.

What to do: Set sensible spending limits, monitor actual performance and protect the cash needed for accepted orders.

2. Positive contribution but a timing gap

The campaign appears commercially worthwhile, but stock and operating costs must be paid before customer receipts become available.

What to do: Confirm available funding, review settlement dates and consider whether affordable arrangements can be negotiated with creditors before increasing sales volume.

3. Weak or negative contribution

Discounts, advertising and fulfilment costs leave little or nothing towards fixed overheads.

What to do: Review the pricing and promotional strategy. Reducing or stopping loss-making product lines may be more sensible than chasing additional turnover.

4. The company can’t fund accepted orders

The business may be unable to complete existing orders, meet refund obligations or pay debts as they fall due.

What to do: Seek urgent professional advice. The board may need to assess whether the business can be rescued, restructured or brought to an orderly close.

What should directors check before increasing Black Friday sales?

Before committing to additional discounts or advertising, directors should work through six questions.

1. Are the campaign assumptions realistic?

Record selling prices, discounts, anticipated order volumes, fulfilment capacity and the expected timing of payments.

2. Can the company fund the stock?

Distinguish stock already owned from stock that must still be purchased. Check supplier credit limits, payment terms and any retention-of-title provisions.

3. What does the cash forecast show?

Prepare a daily view during the campaign and a rolling forecast for at least 13 weeks afterwards. Use actual due dates rather than relying on monthly sales totals.

4. Can accepted orders be fulfilled?

Allow for delivery, staffing, returns, refunds and chargebacks. Don’t assume that all customer receipts will remain available to the company.

5. Can the company meet its other debts?

Compare expected cash with payroll, tax, rent, suppliers and finance payments. A campaign that helps pay historic arrears but leaves the company unable to meet new liabilities isn’t a sustainable solution.

6. Has the board documented its decision?

Record the forecasts, risks, alternatives and reasons for proceeding. Review the position as actual sales, costs and settlement dates become clearer.

When could creditor negotiations help?

If the underlying business is viable but the campaign creates a temporary cash shortfall, early discussions with creditors may help.

For example, a supplier might agree to revised payment dates, or HMRC may consider an affordable payment arrangement for tax arrears.

Any proposal needs to reflect the company’s wider creditor position. An arrangement with one creditor won’t necessarily prevent action by another.

Where several creditors need a more structured solution, a Company Voluntary Arrangement (CVA) may be worth considering.

If the business or its assets could be rescued but creditor pressure makes that difficult, administration may be appropriate in some circumstances.

Where the company is insolvent and there is no realistic, funded route to continued trading, a Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation (CVL) may provide a way to close the business in an orderly manner.

These procedures aren’t automatic consequences of a difficult trading period. The appropriate response depends on the company’s financial position, its prospects and professional advice.

The insolvency procedures linked above relate to England and Wales. Scottish companies should obtain advice on the procedures and legal framework applicable in Scotland.

When does a cash-flow problem become an insolvency concern?

A retailer can have increasing sales and still be insolvent.

Under section 123 of the Insolvency Act 1986, relevant tests include whether a company can pay its debts as they fall due and whether its liabilities, including contingent and prospective liabilities, exceed its assets.

If a retailer can’t pay wages, tax, suppliers, refunds or other debts when due, directors should consider whether the company is insolvent or approaching insolvency.

If insolvency is becoming a serious concern, directors must give appropriate consideration to creditors’ interests. Where insolvent liquidation or administration becomes inevitable, creditors’ interests take priority.

The board should take care not to worsen creditors’ position by continuing an unfunded promotion or accepting orders that the company has no realistic means of fulfilling.

Directors should also protect company assets, keep proper records and obtain professional advice where necessary.

For further information, see the Insolvency Service’s guidance on directors’ duties upon insolvency.

A strong Black Friday sales total doesn’t, by itself, demonstrate that a company can continue trading safely.

Frequently asked questions

Does higher Black Friday turnover mean the company can keep trading?

Not necessarily. Directors need to consider the contribution made by sales, the timing of cash receipts and the company’s ability to meet its liabilities. Higher turnover can actually increase funding requirements where discounts are substantial or fulfilment costs must be paid upfront.

Can payment providers delay Black Friday sales receipts?

Some payment providers have contractual settlement periods, reserve arrangements or other conditions that affect when funds become available. Retailers should check their own contracts and settlement history rather than assuming that all receipts will be immediately accessible.

Can a retailer refuse returns on Black Friday purchases?

A discounted price doesn’t remove statutory consumer rights. Faulty or misdescribed goods may give customers rights to remedies, while many online purchases also carry cancellation rights. The rules depend on the circumstances and applicable exceptions.

For more information, see the government’s guidance on returns and refunds.

When should directors seek insolvency advice?

Directors should seek advice promptly if for example the company can’t fund accepted orders, expects to miss payroll or tax payments, is relying on uncertain funding, or can’t demonstrate how it will meet new liabilities.

Getting advice early can provide more time to assess rescue options and avoid making the company’s position worse.

Talk through the forecast before Black Friday creates a bigger problem

Black Friday can provide a valuable sales opportunity, but it isn’t a substitute for a sustainable business model or a realistic cash-flow plan.

If increased sales are exposing a wider financial problem, we can help you assess the company’s cash position, creditor pressures and available options.

Useful information to have ready includes the latest bank balance, aged creditor and debtor reports, stock commitments, payment-provider terms, campaign costs and the estimated cost of completing accepted orders.

If you’re concerned that your company can’t fund its Black Friday commitments, it’s better to seek advice before the shortfall grows.

Contact Business Rescue Expert for a confidential discussion about your company’s position and the options available.