An HMRC Time to Pay arrangement may give a company a manageable route through tax arrears. But what happens when the rent is overdue, suppliers want cash on delivery and next month’s PAYE is already looming?

The HMRC letter asks for payment. The landlord is chasing the rent. A key supplier won’t release another delivery until its account is brought up to date. Meanwhile, the same bank balance is being asked to solve all three problems.

For directors, the important question isn’t simply whether HMRC will agree to instalments. It’s whether the business can afford those payments while continuing to trade and meeting its other obligations.

What does an HMRC Time to Pay arrangement actually solve?

Is HMRC Time to Pay enough if your company also owes rent and suppliers? It can be, but only where the company can afford the HMRC instalments alongside essential operating costs, new tax liabilities and realistic arrangements with other creditors. HMRC approval doesn’t prevent landlords or suppliers from taking separate action.

HMRC considers each request individually, looking at the amount owed, the company’s financial circumstances and what it can realistically afford. An arrangement isn’t automatic, and HMRC may ask for details of cash flow, spending, other liabilities, available assets and proposed repayments.

There’s no single fixed repayment period that applies to every arrangement. The terms depend on the circumstances and HMRC’s assessment of affordability.

An agreed TTP arrangement can help a company manage its tax arrears, but it isn’t a general business rescue agreement.

It doesn’t bind the landlord, prevent suppliers from pursuing their debts or provide a legal moratorium against creditor action.

Interest may continue to accrue on overdue tax. The company must also keep track of new tax liabilities and contact HMRC promptly if its circumstances change or it can’t meet an agreed payment.

A repayment plan might look affordable on a spreadsheet until the rent, wages, new tax bills and cost of fulfilling next week’s orders are included.

The landlord and suppliers still have their own decisions to make

A landlord may be willing to discuss staged repayment of rent arrears, a temporary concession or revised lease terms. However, these arrangements need to be negotiated separately.

The company’s lease and the circumstances of any enforcement action will affect the available options. Directors shouldn’t assume that agreeing an HMRC payment plan changes the landlord’s legal position.

Suppliers face their own commercial decisions.

Some may agree to continue supplying while arrears are repaid. Others may reduce credit limits, require payment before delivery or suspend further supplies, subject to their contractual terms and applicable law.

This can create a serious cash-flow problem.

A company might be relying on future sales to fund its HMRC instalments, but those sales may depend on receiving goods or materials from a supplier that’s no longer prepared to offer credit.

If a creditor has obtained a judgment, served a statutory demand or threatened a winding-up petition, it’s important to check the documents and relevant deadlines immediately.

A company generally has 21 days to deal with a statutory demand. Failure to do so can provide grounds for a creditor to seek a winding-up order where the legal requirements are met. However, a statutory demand isn’t a necessary first step in every winding-up case.

Negotiations may still be possible, but be sure not to rely on informal discussions as a substitute for responding to legal proceedings.

Run one cash-flow test, not three separate promises

Before committing to a repayment figure, prepare a rolling 13-week cash-flow forecast.

Start with the cash actually available in the company’s bank accounts. Add receipts that are realistically expected, taking account of when customers are likely to pay.

Then include the payments needed to keep the business operating.

The forecast should cover:

  • Wages and payroll costs
  • Rent and other property expenses
  • Energy and essential overheads
  • Suppliers needed to fulfil customer orders
  • Finance and debt repayments
  • VAT, PAYE, Corporation Tax and other tax liabilities falling due
  • Proposed repayments of existing arrears

It’s important to separate historic debts from new obligations.

An aged-creditor list should also identify how much is owed to each creditor, when payment is due and whether enforcement action has been threatened.

What needs to be agreed with each creditor?

Creditorwhat needs agreeingwhat the forecast must show
HMRCTax arrears and a realistic instalment proposalInstalments are affordable alongside new tax obligations
LandlordRent arrears, repayment dates and any revised lease termsPremises costs remain affordable without relying on unconfirmed concessions
SuppliersOutstanding invoices and terms for continuing supplyThe company has sufficient cash to obtain the goods or services needed to generate revenue

The important point is that these agreements must work together.

If the only way to pay HMRC is to delay the next rent payment, use money needed for the next VAT bill or assume a supplier will restore credit it has already withdrawn, the proposed surplus isn’t genuinely available.

A forecast should demonstrate how the company will meet all its essential obligations, not simply how it will satisfy whichever creditor is applying the most pressure.

When might Time to Pay be enough?

Time to Pay may form part of a workable solution where the underlying business remains viable and its arrears arose from a temporary cash-flow interruption.

For example, a major customer may have paid late, but a substantial and verifiable receipt is now expected. Alternatively, the company may have reduced its costs and returned to sustainable trading.

If the business can demonstrate that it will generate sufficient cash to meet its current obligations and repay arrears, a TTP arrangement may provide valuable breathing space.

That assessment becomes stronger where the landlord and important suppliers have also agreed realistic repayment terms.

However, directors need to distinguish between a temporary shortage of cash and an ongoing inability to pay debts.

The key question is whether the company can pay both its historic arrears and its new obligations without allowing other overdue balances to increase.

HMRC’s acceptance of a payment plan doesn’t, by itself, establish that a company is solvent.

When is it no longer just an HMRC problem?

There are warning signs that a company’s difficulties may be more serious than the timing of one tax payment.

These include:

  • Repeated trading losses
  • Tax arrears increasing each quarter
  • Missed HMRC instalments
  • Suppliers refusing essential deliveries
  • Rent arrears continuing to grow
  • Wages or other essential costs going unpaid
  • Cash-flow forecasts that depend on delaying the next tax payment

Where these problems persist, directors may need to consider a wider restructuring or insolvency solution.

Depending on the company’s circumstances, options could include negotiations with major creditors, operational changes, sustainable new finance or a formal insolvency procedure.

A Company Voluntary Arrangement (CVA) may allow a viable business to restructure certain debts through a formal agreement with creditors. However, proposing a CVA doesn’t automatically prevent creditor action, and an arrangement must satisfy the relevant approval requirements.

Administration may be appropriate in some circumstances, particularly where the business needs formal protection while a licensed insolvency practitioner considers the available options. It isn’t suitable for every company and doesn’t guarantee that the original company will survive.

Where rescue isn’t realistic, a Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation (CVL) may provide an orderly way to close an insolvent company.

The appropriate course depends on the company’s financial position, prospects and creditor circumstances.

What are directors’ responsibilities if the company may be insolvent?

A company may be insolvent if it cannot pay its debts as they fall due or if its liabilities exceed its assets.

As financial difficulties become more serious, directors must consider creditors’ interests. Where insolvent liquidation or administration is inevitable, those interests become paramount.

Directors should protect company assets, keep reliable financial records and avoid decisions that unnecessarily worsen creditors’ position.

Particular care is needed before making unusual payments to selected creditors, taking on further commitments or continuing to trade where there’s no realistic prospect of meeting the resulting obligations.

This doesn’t mean every payment to an important supplier is automatically prohibited. The legal position depends on the circumstances, the purpose of the payment and the directors’ duties at the time.

If insolvency is a possibility, obtain professional advice before making significant decisions.

What should a director do now?

If HMRC, the landlord and suppliers are all pressing for payment, the first step is to understand the company’s complete financial position.

  1. List every outstanding liability. Include tax, rent, suppliers, finance, wages and any court or enforcement documents.
  2. Prepare a realistic cash-flow forecast. Look at the next 13 weeks, using cautious assumptions about customer payments and future trading.
  3. Speak to creditors early. Discuss a realistic proposal with HMRC and negotiate separately with the landlord and critical suppliers. Record any agreements in writing.
  4. Check whether the proposals work together. Make sure the company isn’t relying on money already needed for another essential payment.
  5. Seek advice if the figures don’t add up. If the forecast still shows a shortfall, or creditor enforcement is threatened, obtain insolvency and legal advice before making further commitments.

An HMRC Time to Pay arrangement can be a useful tool. But the question is whether it forms part of a workable plan for the whole business — or simply gives one creditor a repayment timetable while everyone else keeps waiting.

If your company is struggling with HMRC arrears alongside pressure from landlords or suppliers, don’t wait until the situation becomes more difficult.

Business Rescue Expert helps company directors assess cash-flow problems, creditor negotiations and the options for rescuing or closing a business.

For a confidential discussion, contact our team or call 0333 939 80 40.

This article concerns limited companies in England and Wales and provides general information rather than advice on individual circumstances. Scottish insolvency procedures and some creditor rights differ.